There Is One Clear Winner In The Corn Vs. Photo voltaic Battle

Join CleanTechnica’s Weekly Substack for Zach and Scott’s in-depth analyses and excessive degree summaries, join our every day publication, and/or observe us on Google Information!

A brand new research carried out by Matthew A. Sturchio, Adam Gallaher, and Steven Grodsky of Cornell College explores the connection between devoting arable land to rising corn or utilizing it for creating photo voltaic power. Printed within the scientific journal PNAS on April 21, 2025, it begins with this introduction:

“Photo voltaic power is commonly framed as a risk to croplands. Nevertheless, huge croplands within the Midwestern United States already help corn ethanol biofuel, a type of power with a larger land-use footprint per unit power (~30×) and potential environmental influence (e.g., extreme fertilizer utility) than photo voltaic power. We envisioned sustainable agro-ecosystems that may consequence from changing a small proportion of corn ethanol croplands into ecologically knowledgeable photo voltaic services (i.e., ecovoltaics). We recognized alternatives the place the strategic placement of ecovoltaic photo voltaic might facilitate enhancement of ecosystem providers like water high quality, pollination providers, and wildlife habitat in crop-dominated ecosystems. Our evaluation gives an ecologically knowledgeable resolution to facilitate a sustainable power transition in croplands by way of co-located photo voltaic power and ecosystem providers.”

In a report concerning the research in Anthropocene Journal by Emma Bryce, the writer writes that photo voltaic power growth is commonly seen as a risk to meals safety in the USA. Photo voltaic could also be all very good, but when it means individuals will go hungry, that’s dangerous, proper? Roughly 12 million hectares (about 30 billion acres) of US farmland — an space the scale of New York State — are at present dedicated to rising corn that isn’t used for meals however for making ethanol gas. What if a few of that acreage at present used to help ethanol was used as a substitute to generate zero emissions electrical energy from photo voltaic panels as a substitute?

What the researchers discovered was that by devoting only a tiny share of that land to photo voltaic panels would dramatically enhance the USA’s photo voltaic power output whereas relieving vital ecological pressures on the land. “Folks need to see farms develop meals, and I believe most individuals would agree with that opinion. The motivation right here was to know whether or not ecovoltaic photo voltaic may very well be a simpler land use technique than utilizing 12 million hectares to develop corn for gas,” stated Sturchio, who’s a researcher on the Cornell College Faculty of Agricultural and Life Sciences and lead writer on the paper.

In keeping with Wikipedia, the USA grew to become the world’s largest producer of ethanol gas in 2005. It produced 15.8 billion gallons of ethanol gas in 2019, up from 13.9 billion gallons in 2011, and from 1.62 billion gallons in 2000. Then comes the kicker. The US authorities mandates that ethanol be a minimum of 10 p.c of each gallon of gasoline bought to be used in motor automobiles. So as to make sure that there may be sufficient ethanol to fulfill that requirement, the federal government subsidizes farmers who develop the corn used to make ethanol. And whereas we might consider these subsidies going to arduous working small farmers, essentially it’s Huge Ag that reaps many of the rewards, a portion of which is dedicated to lobbying the federal authorities to maintain that subsidy intact.

Corn, Ethanol, And Photo voltaic Energy

The researchers started by figuring out the farmland the place corn is grown for ethanol manufacturing within the US. Then they narrowed their search to solely think about corn-for-ethanol farms which can be inside about 3 kilometers {of electrical} transmission websites. That means, solely these farms which can be shut sufficient to the power grid could be thought-about.

The very first thing they found was that 391,137 hectares (~1 million acres) of corn-for-ethanol farmland meets this standards, which is simply 3.2 p.c of all of the land at present dedicated to corn ethanol farming. Changing simply that tiny quantity of land to photo voltaic might yield the identical quantity of power as all corn ethanol farming does yearly within the US. Wait, what? The power from photo voltaic on about 1 million acres of farmland would equal the power obtainable from the ethanol derived from 30 billion acres of corn? Is that this a joke?

No, it isn’t. It’s a clear indication of how inefficient the entire corn for ethanol course of is. Issue within the water, pesticides, and fertilizers wanted to develop 30 billion acres of corn and you start to get an thought about how a lot of a waste of valuable sources the entire corn for ethanol scheme is. If Gruppenfuher Musk actually wished to chop authorities waste, his would ship his DOGE stormtroopers into motion to get rid of the large boondoggle.

However Wait, There’s Extra!

The researchers then went additional to point out that if farmers took a daring leap and coated 46% of land at present used to farm ethanol with photo voltaic panels, that might then generate sufficient power to succeed in the 2050 decarbonization objective for the US. The comparability reveals how a lot decrease the effectivity of rising corn for power is when in comparison with photo voltaic manufacturing. In actual fact, the research says that it might require about 31 hectares of corn ethanol to provide the identical quantity of power generated by one hectare of land coated in photo voltaic panels. Think about that — lower than 4 p.c of that land might generate the power equal of all these acres of corn. That have to be a mistake. How can that presumably be right? However it’s. The numbers don’t lie.

Changing corn with photo voltaic panels on simply 3.2 p.c of farmland would cut back using nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer by about 54.8 million kg and 26.3 million kg, respectively. It might additionally scale back the necessity for irrigation throughout this terrain. What’s extra, the land beneath photo voltaic panels might be planted with perennials and wildflowers that may assist to stabilize soils and scale back run-off, sequester carbon, and diversify farmland with pollinator-friendly vegetation.

Then there’s the potential financial good thing about placing photo voltaic panels on cropland, which might put cash within the pockets of small farmers. The brand new research notes that earlier analysis reveals farmers who lease their land to photo voltaic builders can earn between three and 4 occasions extra per acre than they generate from regular farming. The anti-renewables crazies are all the time beating their breasts and rending their clothes concerning the lack of the agricultural lifestyle as a result of renewables, however nothing disrupts that legendary lifestyle greater than farms that go bankrupt. You’d suppose the farming neighborhood would welcome a method to get extra worth from every acre of land with much less work.

The outcomes of a brand new research on photo voltaic panels and farmland revealed in Nature Sustainability finds that farmers who commit a small share of their land to photo voltaic panels are extra financially steady than those that both go full photo voltaic or incorporate no panels on their land. These crop and photo voltaic farms spend much less on fertilizers and irrigation, whereas the revenue from promoting power greater than offsets any revenue misplaced by farming fewer crops, the research studies.

The Cornell findings recommend that photo voltaic panels could also be rather more of a boon to farmers and meals programs than a risk. “Ecologically-informed photo voltaic power services can scale back the land use footprint of power manufacturing in croplands, assist diversify and restore wildlife habitat in homogenized agricultural landscapes, scale back fertilizer inputs, filter fertilizer runoff, and quickly contribute to emissions discount targets,” Sturchio stated.