Help CleanTechnica’s work by a Substack subscription or on Stripe.
Indonesia has taken a daring and sure problematic step with the announcement of its first, early stage regulatory approval for a nuclear energy mission. Thorcon Worldwide, a Singapore-based developer of molten salt reactors, has acquired permission from Indonesia’s regulator to guage a web site for an illustration plant on Kelasa Island. For a rustic of greater than 270 million folks with electrical energy demand that’s nonetheless rising quickly, this would possibly seem like a turning level. But if one examines historical past, expertise, and the context during which this mission is being launched, the possibilities of it succeeding look vanishingly small.
Indonesia is the world’s largest archipelago, stretching throughout greater than 17,000 islands, with solely about 6,000 of them inhabited. This geography creates monumental challenges for the nationwide grid, which is fragmented into a number of regional programs somewhat than a single interconnected spine. Java and Sumatra host a lot of the nation’s transmission infrastructure, whereas many outlying islands rely upon small remoted grids. Distant communities typically depend on diesel turbines for electrical energy, that are costly to function and create vital native air pollution.
Economically, Indonesia is pushed by useful resource extraction and exports reminiscent of coal, palm oil, nickel, and pure fuel, in addition to a rising manufacturing sector and companies financial system. Tourism, fisheries, and agriculture stay essential contributors, significantly on islands exterior the primary industrial hubs. This mix of dispersed inhabitants, reliance on fossil fuels, and financial dependence on useful resource sectors shapes each the urgency and the problem of Indonesia’s vitality transition.
Indonesia nonetheless depends closely on coal, which supplies about 61% of its electrical energy, with pure fuel and oil supplying a lot of the relaxation. Renewables stay modest, with hydropower contributing round 7%, geothermal about 5%, and photo voltaic simply 1%. The state electrical energy plan units out 71 GW of latest capability by 2034, with about 17 GW from photo voltaic, 16 GW from hydro, and 5 GW from geothermal. Alongside this, the federal government has introduced a goal of 10 GW of nuclear capability by 2040, marking its first dedication to nuclear energy.
If delivered, these additions would elevate renewables to roughly 35% of the nationwide combine whereas additionally introducing nuclear into the system for the primary time. Wanting additional forward, Indonesia targets 75 GW of latest renewable capability by 2035, supported by greater than 10 GW of storage, reflecting the dimensions of funding wanted to diversify away from coal and meet local weather commitments.
Nuclear energy has solely succeeded when sure situations had been in place. Within the mid-twentieth century, giant economies aligned nuclear vitality packages with nuclear weapons packages. They standardized on one design, constructed dozens of gigawatt-scale crops in sequence, educated workforces by government-led packages, and maintained focus for many years. These packages weren’t environment friendly by at this time’s requirements, however they had been coherent and well-resourced.
Nations that didn’t comply with that system, reminiscent of Canada’s stop-start strategy with CANDUs or the the final couple of a long time of western nuclear reactor builds, ended up with blended outcomes and rising prices. Even China, which has mastered megaproject supply, is combating nuclear as a result of it has unfold effort throughout too many designs and has not locked into the mandatory standardization. Whereas nuclear advocates within the west level to China’s construct out as spectacular, it’s years behind on targets and falling additional behind. It solely achieved its 2020 goal in 2024, continues to be properly below its 2% of grid capability goal for 2025 and its scheduled building by 2030 will depart it tens of GW off that concentrate on.
Indonesia has not one of the elements that traditionally led to nuclear success. It has no prior nuclear fleet, no expertise working reactors, no large-scale nuclear workforce, no plans to construct nuclear weapons and no custom of standardized reactor builds. It’s not constructing dozens of ordinary and confirmed GW-scale reactors, however solely 10 GW in complete, beginning with a 500 MW unproven design, and never essentially repeating that one resolution a number of occasions. Up to now they seem to have little political opposition to nuclear, however that doesn’t imply the bipartisan assist required for a two to 4 decade strategic nationwide building program. The nation is signatory to the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and has eradicated extremely enriched uranium that may be transferable to nuclear weapons from the countyr, so there may be army strategic alignment and self-discipline to name upon.
The selection of a molten salt reactor provides one other layer of problem. Molten salt designs had been first examined at Oak Ridge within the Nineteen Sixties. They labored within the lab however bumped into points with corrosion, materials embrittlement, plugging of salt strains, and sophisticated chemistry that needed to be actively managed. They by no means scaled past a number of megawatts of thermal output. In recent times, startups from North America to Scandinavia have revived the idea, promising walk-away security and decrease prices. But not a single one has delivered a industrial plant. Thorcon itself has by no means constructed or operated a reactor, anyplace. It’s proposing to construct giant sealed modules in shipyards and tow them to Indonesia, an strategy that exists solely on paper.
Thorcon’s identify hints that the pink flag of thorium may be within the combine. Thorium has lengthy been held out instead path for nuclear vitality. Thorium-232, when uncovered to neutrons inside a reactor, transmutes into uranium-233, which is fissile and might maintain a sequence response. Advocates have argued that thorium is three to 4 occasions extra plentiful than uranium, produces much less long-lived waste, and creates inherent boundaries to proliferation as a result of the uranium-233 it breeds is contaminated with laborious gamma-emitting uranium-232. Experiments relationship again to the Nineteen Sixties, together with the Oak Ridge molten salt reactor experiment in the US and the Shippingport breeder reactor’s closing thorium core, proved that the gasoline cycle was technically viable.
Germany tried thorium in its pebble-bed reactor, and India constructed a whole nuclear technique round its home thorium reserves, planning a three-stage cycle that will finally depend on superior heavy water reactors fueled with uranium-233 bred from thorium. But in each case, thorium stopped wanting industrial deployment. The complexity of gasoline dealing with, the necessity for an preliminary fissile stock of uranium or plutonium, and the sheer momentum of the uranium-fueled reactor fleet stored thorium within the class of “promising however not delivered.”
Thorcon’s authentic imaginative and prescient was constructed on thorium’s promise. Its very identify, quick for “Thorium Idea,” signaled an intention to commercialize molten salt reactors operating on a thorium cycle. Early designs envisioned dissolving thorium in molten fluoride salt, breeding uranium-233 in situ, and demonstrating the gasoline’s long-touted benefits. However as the corporate moved from idea to attempting to construct an precise plant in Indonesia, pragmatism set in. For a first-of-a-kind energy reactor, counting on thorium would imply untested chemistry, unsure licensing pathways, and even larger danger.
Indonesia’s proposed demonstration plant is due to this fact designed to run on typical low-enriched uranium gasoline dissolved in molten salt, not thorium. Thorium stays a possible long-term choice within the design, however the Indonesian reactor will take the simpler, extra acquainted path to get the mission off the bottom. In different phrases, whereas Thorcon started as a wager on thorium, its first potential real-world deployment has been scaled again to uranium, underscoring how thorium continues to hover on the fringe of nuclear energy somewhat than forming its core.
Bent Flyvbjerg’s work on megaprojects needs to be a warning. He has proven repeatedly that 9 out of ten giant initiatives go over finances and over schedule, and nuclear initiatives are persistently among the many very worst. The typical nuclear construct is greater than 100% over finances and a few decade late. Add in the truth that this can be a first-of-a-kind reactor by an organization with no monitor document, in a rustic with no nuclear infrastructure, and the chance of delivering on time, on finances, and at promised value of electrical energy falls near zero. Even when the mission is finally accomplished, it should nearly actually take for much longer and value far more than marketed, and the advantages to Indonesia won’t match the rhetoric.
The choice paths are clearer and fewer dangerous. Indonesia sits on among the world’s richest geothermal assets and has vital hydro potential. Photo voltaic prices proceed to fall and the archipelago has ample land and rooftops for deployment. With funding in storage, interconnections, and grid modernization, these assets might provide dependable and low-cost electrical energy with out the dangers of nuclear. Worldwide partnerships just like the Simply Vitality Transition Partnership are already funneling billions into renewables and grid upgrades. Constructing out this method is just not trivial, however it doesn’t carry the load of unproven applied sciences, unsure regulation, and the specter of megaproject failure that Thorcon does.
Indonesia’s resolution to approve Thorcon’s web site analysis is a political sign as a lot as a technical step. It displays a want to seem forward-looking and diversified in vitality choices. However except the mission is radically completely different from each different try to construct nuclear in related circumstances, it should turn out to be one other cautionary story. Years will probably be misplaced, billions could also be sunk, and coal might stay within the system longer as a result of assets are tied up in a nuclear dream.
A greater wager could be to double down on renewables, broaden storage, and construct the transmission spine to attach islands and steadiness provide. That path has its personal challenges however rests on confirmed applied sciences already delivering outcomes worldwide. Indonesia has made a daring gesture towards nuclear. The sober evaluation is that it’s going to not repay.
Join CleanTechnica’s Weekly Substack for Zach and Scott’s in-depth analyses and excessive stage summaries, join our day by day e-newsletter, and comply with us on Google Information!
Have a tip for CleanTechnica? Wish to promote? Wish to recommend a visitor for our CleanTech Speak podcast? Contact us right here.
Join our day by day e-newsletter for 15 new cleantech tales a day. Or join our weekly one on high tales of the week if day by day is simply too frequent.
CleanTechnica makes use of affiliate hyperlinks. See our coverage right here.
CleanTechnica’s Remark Coverage
