Assist CleanTechnica’s work by way of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.
Engineered mineral hydrogen is a sublime thought. Water reacts with iron wealthy magnesium and iron wealthy, silica poor igneous rock — ultramafic — from Earth’s mantle rocks to launch hydrogen, and with the appropriate chemistry and temperature you may elevate response charges and acquire a clear product. Within the lab and in fashions this pathway appears to be like promising.
Within the area it asks for a similar muscle tissues that shale, tight gasoline and enhanced geothermal developed over years. You want dependable drilling, completions, stimulation, reservoir monitoring and manufacturing operations. You additionally want an offtaker subsequent door that desires regular molecules for many years. That’s the place the actual world begins to pinch. Simply as with microbial hydrogen underground expertise I checked out lately, what works within the lab begins to appear like nonsense within the area.
The geology just isn’t the place the rigs and frac spreads dwell. The densest service capability in North America sits over the Permian, Eagle Ford and different shale basins. Ultramafic belts are frequent on maps however not in these corridors. Serpentinites — hydrated ultramafic rocks made largely of chrysotile, lizardite, and antigorite — and ophiolites — slices of oceanic crust and higher mantle thrust onto land by tectonics —present up alongside the California Coast Ranges, elements of the Appalachians, items of the Midwest and scattered blocks within the Intermountain West.
There are small overlaps in locations like 4 Corners or elements of Kansas and Michigan, however the heart of gravity for folks, pumps and suppliers is a whole bunch to 1000’s of kilometers away from most of the most potential rocks. That distance provides price, schedule danger and studying friction. It additionally will increase the prospect that crews cycle out and in quite than staying lengthy sufficient to construct a steady craft for this very particular job.
Offtakers will not be the place the rocks are both. Methanol capability in the US clusters on the Gulf Coast as a result of gasoline is affordable, pipelines are thick and ports are shut. Ammonia appears to be like related, with an enormous Louisiana footprint and a secondary band within the Plains and Midwest to serve fertilizer demand. A world scale ammonia plant wants on the order of 176,000 tons of hydrogen per yr, and a world scale methanol plant wants on the order of 200,000 tons per yr.
In case your hydrogen supply sits beside these vegetation you may transfer gasoline just a few kilometers to a header, purify it and feed the method. If the supply sits a great distance from the fence line you have got constructed a second enterprise that should transfer a low density gasoline throughout lengthy distances, or you could convert it to a different service. That erodes the easy “area to flange” narrative that makes engineered mineral hydrogen look tidy on paper.
The physics and chemistry set tight circumstances that have to be met and saved. Hydrogen technology is strongest when water reacts with ferrous iron to grow to be magnetite, releasing hydrogen, which works greatest at just a few hundred levels Celsius. If the rock is cooler, response charges drop. If rust-like coatings cowl the reactive rock floor, the response slows down. If fractures brief circuit circulation in order that water bypasses contemporary floor, charges drop.
Hydrogen purity issues as a result of floor vegetation grow to be massive and energy hungry after they should pull hydrogen out of dilute streams. Microbes within the subsurface can eat hydrogen and decrease purity. The fluids could be very alkaline, which is tough on cement and a few steels. Hydrogen is tiny, diffusive and might embrittle some alloys. Each a type of points has a mitigation, however none are but confirmed on the scale and length that offtakers and lenders require.
Sustained deliverability is a tough gate. Techno financial research usually use a per effectively goal round 175 to 200 kg of hydrogen per hour on the wellhead, with purity at or above about 65%. That’s roughly 4.2 to 4.8 tons per day. Held for 20 years, one effectively would ship on the order of mid tens of 1000’s of tons. That’s numerous rock to contact. Again of the envelope calculations utilizing literature yields of some kilograms of hydrogen per cubic meter of totally reacted peridotite — olivine with some pyroxene — indicate {that a} single profitable effectively should sweep many thousands and thousands of cubic meters of reactive quantity over its life. That’s possible if fracture networks keep open and if stimulation accesses new floor over time.
It isn’t possible if the system will get lined by a skinny, steady movie—like iron-oxide or carbonate — early, if the fractures shut or if operations brief circuit circulation. The analogy to shale just isn’t excellent, however it’s instructive. Shale wells present excessive preliminary charges after which steep declines as a result of the accessible stress and floor space near the effectively get used up. Operators maintain area degree output by consistently drilling new laterals and including levels, not by anticipating single wells to sit down on plateau for many years. An engineered hydrogen area would wish its personal model of that playbook, with deliberate step outs, staged entry to new rock and periodic upkeep interventions, all whereas holding chemistry and purity in bounds.
Attending to that degree of operational maturity takes many at bats in a short while. Shale scaled as a result of 1000’s of wells throughout just a few massive basins let groups study quick. Fluids, proppants, stage spacing, diverters and diagnostics improved as a result of service corporations labored each week in the identical locations and swapped concepts on the espresso truck.
Engineered mineral hydrogen doesn’t have that runway. America possible has solely dozens of Tier 1 prospects once you demand the total system of supply rock, reservoir and seal at accessible depth. The world possible has a whole bunch. Many sit in areas with restricted oilfield companies or with insurance policies that constrain hydraulic stimulation. You possibly can import spreads for a hub, and one hub with 80 to 120 wells is massive sufficient to maintain a crew busy for months, however a sparse map of tasks slows the educational loop. That retains prices excessive, cycle instances lengthy and confidence low for longer than offtakers can tolerate.
The placement of demand and the construction of incentives additionally tilt the sphere. Blue hydrogen just isn’t new chemistry. It’s reforming or partial oxidation of pure gasoline paired with seize and storage of carbon dioxide. It lives the place gasoline lives, which is usually the identical place methanol and ammonia vegetation already sit. It connects to current hydrogen pipelines and to salt cavern storage in some areas. It makes use of normal compressors and purification blocks.
Coverage in lots of international locations helps carbon seize with lengthy lived credit or contracts for distinction. Coverage for clear hydrogen typically helps any low carbon supply, typically provides strict lifecycle accounting guidelines and typically narrows the window for venture begins.
In gasoline wealthy areas the combo of plant places, pipeline entry and coverage help tends to make blue hydrogen simpler to financial institution. The unfold between modeled engineered mineral hydrogen prices and blue hydrogen prices just isn’t massive. Small misses on circulation price or purity can erase it. Lenders take a look at that unfold and see danger.
Regulation issues as a lot as geology and value. Some states have broad restrictions on hydraulic fracturing, and lots of jurisdictions in Europe do as effectively. That doesn’t cease all types of stimulation, however it provides time and uncertainty. Electrical reservoir stimulation is promising and avoids a few of the points that drive water primarily based fracturing opposition, however it nonetheless requires deep wells, excessive voltage gear, rigorous monitoring and a receptive regulator. Builders can thread these needles in just a few locations, however it isn’t a recipe for quick replication throughout many basins. A growth mannequin that depends upon new offtake vegetation standing up beside first of a form subsurface techniques in jurisdictions which might be studying on the job is a tough promote.
It’s honest to ask what must be true for engineered mineral hydrogen to deserve plant scale offtake. The checklist is brief and clear. A area trial would wish to carry per effectively charges at or above the goal with steady purity for a yr, not a month. It will want to point out that chemical or thermal upkeep restores efficiency when passivation or microbes drag it down. It will want to point out that restimulation can attain new rock from the identical pad with out dropping containment or purity. It will must run a small hub of a number of dozen wells right into a plant header and show that the gathering, compression and purification work at scale with out shock outages. It will must do all of that in a spot the place coverage is regular and the place service depth is actual, and it might must line up an offtaker that’s prepared to signal for 15 to twenty years. That may be a tall stack. It isn’t not possible, however it’s uncommon in extraction historical past for brand new subsurface techniques to leap straight to bankable on the primary or second attempt.
There are glimmers of hope for a few of this. Utah Forge and Fervo are experimenting with fracturing laborious crystalline rock for enhanced geothermal, which my evaluation suggests is a area rife with black swans. There may be some transferability from that to engineered mineral hydrogen. However it doesn’t transfer the expert sources or the methanol and shale vegetation to the great ultramafic zones. Companies pursuing engineered mineral hydrogen embody Vema Hydrogen, Halliburton, EXLOG, and Eden GeoPower, every working to stimulate water–rock reactions in ultramafic formations to provide hydrogen at scale, and a pair are massive established oilfield companies corporations, presumably looking for one thing to do with their equipment and other people with the decline of shale oil and gasoline looming, and actually already pinching this yr.
None of this writes off the underlying chemistry. Water rock reactions make hydrogen naturally. Ultramafics are frequent worldwide. Small pilots are price doing effectively, with cautious measurement and open publication of outcomes. There’s a doable path the place engineered mineral hydrogen fills area of interest markets, proves out a handful of rock sorts and develops a small however succesful service craft. The declare that it’ll anchor world scale ammonia and methanol offtake within the subsequent funding cycles wants greater than promise. It wants lengthy, clear information and a easy story for crews, vegetation and regulators within the locations we truly construct issues.
And, after all, the premise that dozens of fine websites within the US and a whole bunch globally would possibly flip into a brand new power supply must be handled as ludicrous hyperbole.
In a world organized otherwise this might look higher. If ultramafic belts sat below the Gulf Coast and if ammonia and methanol vegetation have been scattered throughout these belts, the educational curve may be brief and the offtake danger small. On this planet now we have, the rigs and crews are in shale areas. The large chemical vegetation are close to gasoline hubs and ports. Most of the ultramafic targets are someplace else. Fracking ultramafic rock economically will take many cycles of trial and error, and there will not be sufficient venture websites in pleasant locations to climb that curve quick.
The economics between engineered mineral hydrogen and blue hydrogen are shut, and the coverage and regulatory image pushes capital towards blue in the identical corridors. That mixture makes first of a form engineered mineral hydrogen hubs with long run offtake unlikely to succeed in bankability quickly, if ever. If a developer proves in any other case with sustained charges, regular purity and a contract subsequent door, that might be a welcome consequence. Till then, the prudent learn is that engineered mineral hydrogen may be technically and economically viable in one other world, and that on this one it faces a map and a market that time to a special consequence.
Join CleanTechnica’s Weekly Substack for Zach and Scott’s in-depth analyses and excessive degree summaries, join our each day publication, and comply with us on Google Information!
Have a tip for CleanTechnica? Wish to promote? Wish to counsel a visitor for our CleanTech Speak podcast? Contact us right here.
Join our each day publication for 15 new cleantech tales a day. Or join our weekly one on high tales of the week if each day is just too frequent.
CleanTechnica makes use of affiliate hyperlinks. See our coverage right here.
CleanTechnica’s Remark Coverage
