Tesla Mannequin Y Rear Door Emergency Launch Hack. Redesign In Progress.

Help CleanTechnica’s work via a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

Two weeks in the past, I wrote an article a couple of couple in Virginia who’re suing Tesla, claiming they have been trapped inside their Mannequin Y after it collided with a utility pole in 2023. An off-duty first responder rushed to the stricken couple, however the exterior door latch was not working. He proceeded to interrupt the window within the driver’s door, however then didn’t know the way to discover the mechanical door launch. The motive force was pulled to security via the window opening, however the passenger needed to look ahead to the Jaws of Life to reach.

The inside entrance door emergency launch is pretty easy to function. Simply pull up the lever situated on the entrance of the arm relaxation to activate it, however it’s matte black and blends in completely with the remainder of the armrest/window switches part. In case you don’t know it’s there, it could as properly be on the darkish aspect of the moon for all the nice it’s going to do.

Opening the entrance doorways in an emergency is feasible, however discovering the emergency launch for the rear doorways isn’t. On the backside of every rear door is a storage compartment designed for holding water bottles, sun shades, and the same old bric-a-brac individuals convey with them once they go for a journey in a automotive. It’s matte black. On the backside of the storage space is a rubber cowl that can also be matte black. Beneath that cowl is a tiny hatch within the backside of the compartment, additionally matte black.

Open the hatch and you will note a wire with a chunk of white foam tape wrapped round it. Pull on that wire to function the mechanical door launch — if you will get a grip on the top. It’s proper there the place you’ll be able to see it, however getting your fingers into the small opening isn’t all that simple. The top of the wire tends to get pushed deeper into the door cavity until you already know exactly what you’re doing.

Actually, if you’re dazed after an accident and don’t know the way to take away the rubber cowl, open the hatch, and seize the top of the cable launch, your odds of getting out of the car are basically zero.

Tesla Fails This Security Check

We now have been writing about Tesla and its concentrate on security because the first Mannequin S rolled off the road in Fremont. And but, the corporate has despatched tons of of 1000’s of automobiles into the world with what can solely be described as a probably deadly defect. How might that be? We do not know, however it’s not an excellent search for the top of an organization who thinks he’s value $1 trillion.

Tesla shrugs and says its automobiles adjust to all relevant federal security requirements, which is technically right however glosses over the truth that these federal security requirements concentrate on surviving a crash, not getting out of a car afterwards. Frankly we anticipate extra from Tesla.

Saying the automobiles adjust to relevant security requirements is the sort of simple excuse making that’s typical of the business, just like the faulty ignition switches that GM refused to exchange or the faulty Pintos from Ford that had a behavior of bursting into flames when struck from behind. Disgrace on Tesla for taking the simple method out as an alternative of giving their clients the upper than regular commonplace of security individuals thought they have been getting once they determined to purchase a Tesla.

After I wrote that article, I did some analysis on-line and located the issue assorted a bit from mannequin to mannequin and by mannequin yr. I discovered a pair of straps on Amazon with vivid yellow ends that connect to the mechanical cable pull. They price $9.00, which is an inexpensive value to pay for peace of thoughts.

It’s not an ideal resolution — somebody unfamiliar with Teslas could not know to search for them — but it surely provides me a way of doing one thing to scale back the hazard. Within the images under, I’ll present you ways troublesome it’s to find the emergency cable pulls and the way to set up these little beauties.

Let’s start with a photograph of precisely what that storage compartment on the backside of the rear doorways seems like. I illuminated it with a flashlight, however with out that mild, it seems like a black gap. Every thing down there’s matte black and solely somebody who has performed their analysis would know there’s a detachable rubber cowl down there.

Eradicating that little bit of rubber isn’t any simple job. It’s best achieved by prying on it with a small screwdriver. In case you don’t have a flashlight and a small screwdriver, you’re out of luck. Here’s what that piece of rubber seems like after it’s eliminated:

After getting the rubber out, you’ll be able to see the hatch cowl that provides entry to the cable launch. Belief me on this. Opening that cowl with no small screwdriver is troublesome and discovering it with no flashlight is nearly unimaginable. There’s nothing to point how the hatch opens. Are you able to think about making an attempt to do that after being in a critical collision whereas the automotive is starting to fill with smoke?

When you open the hatch cowl, you will note a strip of white foam tape that covers the loop on the finish of the discharge cable. Getting your fingers on it’s difficult. To put in the pull straps, you must strip the froth tape away — not the best factor to do in a really confined area.

Subsequent, finagle the lock ring on the top of the strap via the top of the cable launch — a job that may be simpler with three arms, however that merely isn’t potential in such a slender area. Be affected person and provides your self time to get it proper. You would possibly suppose after getting performed one aspect, the opposite aspect can be simpler, however that isn’t the case.

Working within the area out there is a job greatest left to people who find themselves infinitely affected person. I’m not a kind of individuals! Watch out while you’re poking your fingers via the entry cowl. There are different wires within the neighborhood and also you don’t wish to be tugging on the incorrect factor.

Now you’re prepared to shut the entry cowl and reinsert the rubber liner. If you end up performed, the whole lot ought to seem like this.

As soon as the duty was accomplished, my lengthy struggling spouse requested, “What if somebody wonders what this little yellow tab is for and decides to drag it whereas the automotive is in movement?” Good query. Individuals generally tend to mess with issues, so her query is sort of applicable. If we level it out and clarify why it’s there, we threat somebody pulling on it simply to see what occurs. Or individuals might turn into nervous about driving within the again seat.

If we don’t point out it, we threat a rear seat passenger not understanding what to do if the individuals in entrance are unconscious or unable to provide directions. For the second, we’ve got determined to not give everybody who rides within the again seats a tutorial. There actually is nobody dimension matches all resolution to this dilemma.

A Redesign Is In The Works

The main target of this text is on the inside door launch mechanisms, that are powered by the onboard 12-volt battery. So are the outside door handles. If there is no such thing as a 12-volt energy, touching the outside or inside door releases accomplishes nothing. These electrical door controls are a method cool characteristic of Tesla cars (and plenty of different automobiles as properly), however regulators within the US, EU, and China are starting to get involved concerning the security of passengers after an accident.

In keeping with Bloomberg, Franz von Holzhausen, the chief designer for the corporate since without end, now says Tesla is exploring methods to mix the digital and guide door-release mechanisms, that are presently in separate areas. He stated the choice is meant to make the handles extra intuitive for occupants in “a panic scenario.” Properly, Franz, it’s about rattling time, don’t you suppose?

NHTSA opened an investigation this week into whether or not some Tesla doorways are faulty, citing incidents by which exterior handles stopped working and trapped youngsters inside. The probe, which covers an estimated 174,290 Mannequin Y SUVs from the 2021 mannequin yr, “may even assess the strategy utilized by Tesla to provide energy to the door locks and the reliability of the relevant energy provides,” the company stated.

The door deal with design isn’t distinctive to Tesla, however the carmaker has popularized sure traits, together with flush-to-the-door handles. Critics have stated the design can complicate rescue efforts and put the onus on passengers to search out guide launch latches they’re not accustomed to utilizing.

In China this week, a prime regulator is claimed to be contemplating a ban on absolutely hid door handles, and Europe has carried out incremental measures to enhance post-crash rescue protocols, Bloomberg says. Tesla is presently learning particulars of the potential change in China, von Holzhausen stated, and is able to make needed modifications. “We’ll have a very good resolution for that,” he stated.

That’s fantastic information, Franz, but it surely doesn’t clarify why Tesla took so lengthy to handle a obtrusive defect that places individuals’s lives in danger or how any modifications shall be retrofitted to automobiles already manufactured. Tesla, as per normal, had nothing to say when requested for clarification by Bloomberg. It has an obligation to guarantee present homeowners that the corporate they trusted is taking these questions of safety critically, and that it has a viable plan to handle them.