2008 Headline From The Onion Echoes Strongly Immediately

Help CleanTechnica’s work by way of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

Below a latest article I wrote about Tesla’s robotic manifesto probably being simply an funding Hail Mary from Tesla, reader “Assaf” made the next remark:

“Effectively, judging by the inventory ticker, the Wall Road scammers and their victims fortunately lapped this crap ‘Grasp Plan’ up.

“I’d not count on any totally different from Wall Road and from individuals who imagine in Wall Road.

“The Onion nailed it already in July 2008: ‘Recession-Plagued Nation Calls for New Bubble To Make investments In’“

It’s an attention-grabbing level, and an excellent article from 2008! And this does get to a root query I’ve been questioning for fairly some time.

The economic system goes up and down, however, generally, there’s a category of individuals with a superb sum of money to put money into the inventory market, and they’re actually not that harm by financial ups and downs. They don’t wrestle to pay the payments or purchase meals in arduous financial instances, and so they don’t must promote shares to get by. Roughly, individuals who have invested within the inventory marketplace for years and have numerous additional money for that objective don’t wish to go take that cash out of the inventory market (particularly if that may end in having to pay much more in taxes). A method or one other, they’re hoping their invested {dollars} will develop rather a lot over time, and they’re simply searching for the following alternative to have them try this. So, even when issues are going badly, they’re inclined to go away their cash out there.

Within the case of Tesla particularly, for a very long time, it was recognized as a key development firm that was disrupting an enormous trade. Skeptics thought Tesla would die for years, but it surely survived and thrived. As the corporate received greater and greater, after which turned worthwhile, an increasing number of “good cash” was going into Tesla. The corporate was anticipated to maintain quickly innovating and quickly rising. One might nonetheless attempt to argue the previous is going down (it’s quickly innovating), however the latter has very clearly not been the case for the previous couple of years (Tesla has been declining, not rising). Tesla retains dropping gross sales yr over yr, however there’s no apparent alternative for it. What different firm stands alone within the disruption of an enormous trade? Even when Tesla’s story has died a bit, who’s received the following large Tesla story?

This text is just not solely about Tesla, although. Cash can be getting poured into Bitcoin, NVIDIA, Oracle, and others. Individuals who have some huge cash usually are not going to place all that cash below their mattresses. They wish to put it into shares (or currencies) of the longer term. They’re determined to discover a place the place their cash can see hypergrowth.

Tesla, for years, was the clear inventory for hypergrowth, but it surely was additionally an idea that was simple to understand — a brand new sort of automobile firm that had virtually the entire market to overcome. I believe some huge cash is staying within the inventory as a result of there’s no apparent various, no different easy and compelling firm story that’s pulling individuals away from TSLA and into a brand new path. The place is the “subsequent TSLA?” There is no such thing as a clear subsequent TSLA. So why not simply hold that cash in TSLA and hope that Tesla finds a strategy to innovate disruptively once more and blow up in a brand new market? Tesla has solely actually performed this in a single market — automobiles. It failed within the solar energy market on this regard. It has failed to this point in heavy-duty vehicles. It’s doing alright in battery storage methods and grid companies, however the scale of that’s nonetheless questionable and unproven. It’s about 5 years late in hitting robotaxi targets. Sure, it has performed superb issues within the automobile market, however in any other case, it’s principally simply talked about doing superb issues. However … the place else to place one’s cash? Who else has a extra compelling story and clear success across the nook? And if there isn’t any apparent selection, why not simply keep on with Tesla and see if it could actually dwell as much as Elon Musk’s hype?

Will TSLA change into an enormous funding bubble? Will sh** lastly hit the fan with a combination of dropping gross sales and failed AI objectives? Who is aware of, but when it does, we are able to come again to that Onion article: the nation calls for a brand new bubble to put money into. In fact, it’s not the nation as an entire. It’s the funding nation. They want some large development, and ideally some apparent firm, to put money into. Till Tesla crashes (greater than it has been crashing) and misses extra large targets (greater than it has been lacking large targets), it seems the corporate will retain an enormous market cap — effectively past something some other auto firm has. The hype round AI and robots nonetheless has individuals hanging on. If a big portion of the funding nation does lose religion in Tesla, although, these traders actually need one other sizzling supertrend to place their cash into.